Customer Reviews:

0 out of 0 people found the following review helpful
Customer Id: APZMEC527G9PK 2008-11-14
 
Review Summary: lasted 12 hours....
 
Review Content: I got my 1tb My Book on Monday, it lasted a whole day and then started smelling of burnt electronics. Contacted Amazon, they were excellent and sent me a replacement Thursday, started it up, backed up some files. Got home backed up some more files from home pc then suddenly it died. It lasted 8 hours.

Thankfully Amazon seem really good about replacing dodgy products but why stock them in the first place.
 
 
 

0 out of 0 people found the following review helpful
Customer Id: A3H5IGQIFPM204 2008-11-13
 
Review Summary: Quality Product
 
Review Content: This is a relatively small, sleek external HDD. I've had a 250GB WD My Book for over 2 years and it still works perfectly so there was no doubt about buying WD again. This drive is smaller in size than the 250GB and has a glossy plastic finish and is extremely quiet. The only real difference is the addition of an extra light which flashes constantly when the drive is in use (i.e. playing an mp3 file) - it seems unnecessary.


The drive comes with pre-installed trial backup software and some other unnecessary software. I'd advise anyone who doesn't want this software to perform the Quick Format function on the drive and this will remove this software. If you are using the drive for straight forward backing up of mp3, jpeg, etc. I'd recommend using the open source (free) "Cobian Backup" software (which is NOT pre-installed) instead of either the MS backup software you may have on your PC (it backups unnecessary MS components) or the pre-installed trial backup software. It's easy to use and runs quietly in the background.

In summary, highly recommended. At a cost of approximately 12p per GB, it's a bargain.

Edit: It would appear that Amazon is publishing reviews for the 500GB My Book on the 1TB My Book product page and vice-versa. This is a review for the 500GB My Book.
 
 
 

0 out of 0 people found the following review helpful
Customer Id: A3HEZYGDEE5PXU 2008-11-13
 
Review Summary: "Failure rate of less than 1%"?
 
Review Content: I ordered one of these drives about a month ago, deciding that although lots of people had warned against it, there were probably just as many satisfied customers who didn't bother to leave a review. Just like I'm doing now, probably most people only leave a review when they've had a problem with a product.

Unfortunately the light on the front of the drive just kept flashing and it just wouldn't connect to my Mac. I emailed Western Digital tech support and they suggested I returned it as it was faulty.

Undeterred, I ordered a replacement. When I plugged it in nothing happened for about 3 minutes and then it appeared on my Mac desktop. I have since found out that this delay was because the drive is formatted in FAT32 which means it's recognisable by Mac and PC, however it takes longer to be recognised by Mac and so various websites recommended that if you're only using it on a Mac to reformat it using Mac's disk utility tool. The next day I switched on the drive to reformat it and nothing happened. Again I contacted Western Digital tech support and they said that it appeared to be faulty and to return it, stating "This drive is usually very reliable as many of our customers have had no issues with it. We have a less than 1% failure rate with our drives."

In that case I must be extremely unlucky!

There does seem to be a high failure rate with these drives. Even if it works to begin with, from other people's reviews and my experience it seems that the drive can fail at any time, which defeats the object of using this drive to back up your data. I'm now looking for another drive of a similar size and price but that is reliable - if anyone has any recommendations that would be appreciated!
 
 
 

0 out of 0 people found the following review helpful
Customer Id: A3OO8847RAII53 2008-11-09
 
Review Summary: Very Poor Longevity
 
Review Content: I've not got this specific model but I've had a 500GB WD external hard drive for just over 18 months and it has died. There is no help from WD because of course it's out of warranty. If this is the longevity of their products then it's very, very poor for something that just sits on a shelf and should be available when disaster strikes. I for one will not be entertaining WD products ever again.
 
 
 

0 out of 0 people found the following review helpful
Customer Id: AP0FDMWE7NDZV 2008-11-08
 
Review Summary: After a while the drives of WD become unreadable
 
Review Content: Well I thought that WD was a reliable brand in hard drives and external hard drives. I was mistaken. My first external hard drive was on WD 500GB MyBook, it died after 8 months of use. I managed to save most of my data into another WD external hard drive that I bought, this time 1TB. This one died just 3 months after the purchase...

The worse is that I own a third one WD 1 TB external drive...It has not failed me yet, but after reading all those reviews in the net I do not believe that it will last much longer. Also one friend of mine that has bought one WD 500Gb had the same problem after a few months of use.

I am sending my drives to WD for replacement, but I am not optimistic at all that they will not fail me again..

Stay away from those Drives!!